Fabrication and Optimization of Alginate Membranes for Improved Wastewater Treatment

Alginate, a naturally occurring biopolymer extracted from brown algae, presents a promising avenue for developing sustainable and efficient membranes for wastewater treatment. This review comprehensively examines recent advancements in the fabrication, modification, and application of alginate-based membranes for effective water purification. The paper delves into various fabrication techniques, including casting, electrospinning, and 3D printing, which influence the structural and functional properties of the resulting alginate membranes. To enhance performance, strategies such as crosslinking, incorporation of porogens, and surface functionalization are employed. These modifications optimize crucial properties like mechanical strength, porosity, selectivity, and antifouling resistance. Furthermore, Response Surface Methodology (RSM) has emerged as a valuable tool for systematically optimizing fabrication parameters, enabling researchers to identify optimal conditions for achieving desired membrane characteristics. The integration of alginate membranes with biological treatment processes, such as phycoremediation (utilizing microalgae) and mycoremediation (employing fungi), offers a synergistic approach to enhance wastewater treatment efficiency. By immobilizing these microorganisms within the alginate matrix, their bioremediation capabilities are amplified, leading to improved pollutant degradation and nutrient removal. In conclusion, alginate-based membranes demonstrate significant potential as a sustainable and effective technology for wastewater treatment. Continued research and development, focusing on optimizing fabrication processes and exploring innovative integration strategies with biological systems, will further advance the application of alginate membranes in addressing the pressing global challenge of water pollution.

The increasing industrialization and expanding global population have led to a significant surge in wastewater generation, posing a serious threat to human health and the environment. Conventional wastewater treatment methods, such as activated sludge processes, while effective in removing some pollutants, often suffer from several limitations. These include high energy consumption, the generation of substantial amounts of sludge, and limited efficacy in removing emerging contaminants and recalcitrant pollutants [1].

Membrane technology has emerged as a promising alternative due to its high efficiency, modularity, and versatility in removing a wide range of pollutants [2]. Among various membrane materials, alginate, a naturally derived biopolymer extracted from brown algae, has garnered significant attention for its potential in wastewater treatment applications [3].

Alginate membranes offer several advantages. Their natural origin and inherent biodegradability under specific conditions contribute to a reduced environmental impact compared to synthetic polymers [4]. Recent research has demonstrated the potential of alginate-based biocomposite membranes as sustainable alternatives for wastewater treatment [5].

Furthermore, alginate membranes exhibit remarkable versatility. Researchers can modify their properties through various approaches, such as incorporating nanoparticles or other functional materials, to enhance their ability to capture specific pollutants [6]. For instance, Li, et al. [7] demonstrated the successful enhancement of pollutant removal efficiency through the incorporation of nanoparticles within the alginate matrix.

Moreover, alginate membranes can be fabricated with precisely controlled pore sizes, allowing for selective permeation of water while effectively blocking pollutants [8]. Shahid, et al. [9] investigated the critical role of pore size in determining the pollutant rejection performance of alginate membranes.

Despite their promising potential, alginate membranes also face certain limitations that require careful consideration. One significant challenge is their inherent mechanical weakness, particularly when exposed to harsh wastewater conditions. Liu, et al. [2] explored various strategies, including the incorporation of reinforcing materials, to enhance the mechanical strength and durability of alginate membranes.

Another critical challenge lies in achieving an optimal balance between high pollutant rejection and high water permeability. Developing membranes that effectively capture a wide range of pollutants while maintaining high flux rates remains an area of active research [10]. Xu, et al. [11] investigated innovative membrane structures to address this critical trade-off.

Furthermore, the presence of complex organic matter in wastewater can significantly impact the biodegradability of alginate membranes [12]. Wang, et al. [13] investigated strategies to enhance the biodegradability of alginate membranes in complex wastewater environments, ensuring their long-term sustainability.

Integrating biological treatment processes: Exploring synergistic approaches

Traditional wastewater treatment methods often struggle to effectively remove persistent pollutants and emerging contaminants. Mycoremediation, which utilizes the metabolic capabilities of fungi to degrade pollutants, and phycoremediation, which leverages the bioremediation potential of microalgae, offer promising alternatives [14,15].

Mycoremediation provides a powerful tool for degrading a wide range of pollutants through enzymatic degradation and biosorption [16]. For instance, Yasar, et al. [17] demonstrated the effective degradation of organic pollutants in slaughterhouse wastewater using fungal-based treatment systems.

Phycoremediation offers several advantages, including the removal of nutrients (such as nitrogen and phosphorus), the degradation of various pollutants, and the potential for biofuel production [15]. Xin, et al. [18] investigated the efficacy of microalgae in removing nitrogen and phosphorus from diverse wastewater sources.

This study embarks on a comprehensive exploration of alginate membranes, focusing on their development, application, and potential for transformative impact in wastewater treatment, particularly in the context of treating challenging effluents from slaughterhouses. A key objective is to conduct a thorough review of recent advancements in the field, encompassing research on membrane fabrication, modification techniques, and emerging applications.

Furthermore, this study aims to assess the feasibility and potential benefits of integrating alginate membrane technologies with complementary biological treatment processes, specifically mycoremediation, and phycoremediation. By exploring synergistic interactions between these technologies, the study seeks to identify innovative and integrated treatment solutions that can enhance overall treatment efficiency and sustainability.

A critical aspect of this study involves identifying critical knowledge gaps and areas requiring further research to advance the development and implementation of alginate membrane-based wastewater treatment systems. By pinpointing areas of uncertainty and outlining future research directions, this study aims to guide and stimulate further research efforts in this promising area.

Ultimately, this study will contribute to a deeper understanding of the potential of alginate membranes in sustainable wastewater treatment. The findings and insights generated through this research will provide valuable guidance for the development and implementation of innovative and integrated treatment solutions that address the growing challenges associated with wastewater management.

Alginate membranes: A promising platform for waste-water treatment

Derived from brown algae, alginate emerges as a promising biopolymer for developing sustainable wastewater treatment membranes. Its inherent properties, such as biocompatibility and biodegradability, make it an attractive alternative to synthetic materials. Alginate membranes exhibit several advantageous characteristics that contribute to their suitability for wastewater treatment applications (Figure 1).

Firstly, alginate is a biodegradable material, meaning it can decompose under specific environmental conditions [4]. This inherent biodegradability minimizes potential environmental impacts associated with membrane disposal or accidental release, promoting a more sustainable approach to wastewater treatment. Furthermore, alginate is biocompatible, ensuring minimal harm to aquatic organisms or the surrounding ecosystem in the event of membrane degradation or accidental release [3].

Secondly, alginate membranes possess high porosity, a critical characteristic for efficient wastewater treatment. The pore size and distribution within the alginate matrix can be carefully controlled during fabrication, allowing for selective permeation of water while effectively blocking pollutants [8]. Shahid, et al. [9] emphasized the crucial relationship between pore size and pollutant rejection performance, highlighting the importance of tailoring pore structures to the specific contaminants present in the wastewater stream. This control over porosity enables the design of membranes optimized for the removal of specific pollutants, such as heavy metals, dyes, or organic contaminants.

Thirdly, alginate membranes exhibit remarkable versatility. Their properties can be readily modified through various techniques to enhance their performance for specific wastewater treatment applications [6]. For instance, crosslinking with cations, such as calcium, significantly improves the mechanical stability of the membranes, enabling their use in more demanding environments. Additionally, the incorporation of additives, such as nanoparticles, can enhance the selectivity and adsorption capacity of the membranes for targeted pollutants [7].

Finally, alginate is a relatively abundant and readily available biopolymer, making it a cost-effective option for membrane fabrication compared to some synthetic materials [6]. This economic advantage contributes to the overall sustainability and affordability of alginate-based wastewater treatment technologies.

While alginate membranes offer numerous advantages, certain limitations need to be addressed to ensure their widespread adoption in practical wastewater treatment applications. One major challenge is the relatively low mechanical strength of alginate membranes, particularly when exposed to harsh environments with high pressures or turbulent flow conditions. Strategies such as crosslinking with stronger agents and the incorporation of reinforcing agents, such as nanoparticles or other polymers, are being actively explored to enhance the mechanical stability and durability of alginate membranes for real-world applications [19].

Another critical challenge lies in balancing high selectivity for target pollutants with good water permeability. Achieving a high degree of selectivity while maintaining adequate water flow is crucial for efficient wastewater treatment [10]. Ongoing research focuses on developing advanced alginate membrane structures with optimized pore size distribution and surface modifications, such as the incorporation of functional groups or the creation of hierarchical pore structures, to enhance selectivity and permeability for a wide range of pollutants [11].

Furthermore, membrane fouling, the accumulation of organic and inorganic matter on the membrane surface, can significantly hinder performance [8]. This phenomenon can lead to a decline in water flux, increased energy consumption, and ultimately, reduced treatment efficiency. Strategies such as surface modification, the incorporation of anti-fouling agents, and the development of self-cleaning membranes are being investigated to mitigate fouling and ensure long-term operational stability [8].

Finally, the biodegradability of alginate membranes in complex wastewater environments can be influenced by the presence of various organic and inorganic compounds. The rate of biodegradation may be slower in complex wastewater matrices compared to simpler environments [20]. Research efforts are underway to investigate strategies to enhance biodegradability in complex wastewater environments, such as modifying the alginate structure, incorporating enzymes to accelerate degradation, or developing strategies for controlled biodegradation to ensure a balanced approach to membrane sustainability [21].

Alginate membranes offer a promising platform for sustainable wastewater treatment due to their inherent biocompatibility, biodegradability, and versatility. By addressing the challenges related to mechanical stability, selectivity, and biodegradability through innovative strategies such as advanced materials engineering, surface modification, and process optimization, researchers can further enhance the performance and broaden the applicability of alginate membranes in real-world wastewater treatment applications.

Aiginate membrane fabrication approaches for various applications

Alginate membranes can be made in various ways, each affecting their usefulness for wastewater treatment (Figure 2).

Here, we focus on methods relevant to this research, like dissolving and gelation. Solvent Casting: A common method where alginate solution is poured on a mold and dries to form a thin film [6]. Adjusting the alginate concentration and drying conditions controls the membrane’s properties. Precipitation Method: Sodium alginate solution is dipped in a calcium chloride bath, making it gel with calcium ions. This technique is simple and allows large-scale production by changing solution concentration, dip time, and bath composition. Electrostatic Fiber Formation: This method uses an electric field to spin thin alginate fibers onto a collector, forming a mesh-like membrane [22]. Electrospinning allows for membranes with well-connected pores and a large surface area, beneficial for wastewater treatment. Dissolution-Gelation (focus method): This common method involves dissolving alginate in water and adding a crosslinking agent, typically calcium, to make it gel and form a membrane [6]. It’s simple and cheap and allows control over membrane properties by varying ingredients and conditions. However, the membranes may not be strong enough for high-pressure wastewater treatment. 3D printing: A new technique using 3D printing to create complex alginate membranes with specific shapes and channels [3]. This allows precise control over membrane design, potentially improving their performance for certain wastewater treatment processes. However, bioprinting (3D printing) is still under development and requires specialized equipment, limiting its current use.

Techniques of cross-linking fabrication

Making strong and stable alginate membranes for wastewater treatment relies on a process called crosslinking. This involves linking alginate chains together with either permanent bonds or ionic attractions, significantly improving the membrane’s sturdiness [6]. Here’s a look at common crosslinking agents used: Calcium Champs: Calcium ions (Ca²⁺) are the go-to crosslinking agent for alginate membranes due to their prevalence and ease of use. The process dips the sodium alginate membrane in a calcium chloride (CaCl₂) solution, forming ionic bonds between Ca²⁺ and alginate’s carboxylate groups. The strength of these crosslinks depends on the CaCl₂ bath’s concentration and how long the membrane soaks in it. Multivalent Metal Alternatives: Beyond calcium, other metal ions like aluminum (Al³⁺) and iron (Fe³⁺) can also crosslink alginate membranes [3]. These can create stronger bonds than Ca²⁺ but might introduce problems like potential toxicity or limitations in working with certain wastewaters. Cross-linking Reagents: Synthetic agents like glutaraldehyde can form permanent bonds between alginate chains [8]. While generally offering superior strength compared to ionic crosslinking, they might raise environmental and potential toxicity concerns.

This research focuses on using calcium chloride (CaCl₂) and a combination of CaCl₂ and sodium tetraborate as crosslinking agents. By optimizing the crosslinking process, we aim to achieve the ideal balance between strength, porosity, and biodegradability for alginate membranes treating slaughterhouse wastewater.

Enhancing alginate membranes for wastewater treatment

While alginate membranes show great promise for wastewater treatment, their inherent properties and constraints can be mitigated through diverse modification techniques aimed at enhancing their effectiveness. This section examines various methods to modify alginate membranes, including the use of porogens, stabilizers, and anti-fouling agents, to optimize their attributes for efficient wastewater treatment applications.

Porogen-mediated modification of alginate membranes: Alginate, a naturally derived biopolymer, offers a versatile platform for membrane development due to its biocompatibility, biodegradability, and ease of processing. However, enhancing its inherent properties, such as porosity and permeability, is crucial for many applications. To this end, researchers employ various porogens to introduce controlled porosity within the alginate matrix.

One of the primary methods to improve the efficiency of alginate membranes in wastewater treatment is through membrane modification. This section explores various techniques for modification, focusing particularly on porogen modification to regulate pore structure, thereby enhancing membrane permeability and selectivity. Porosity is a critical attribute of alginate membranes that governs water permeation and pollutant rejection. Porogen modification involves incorporating foreign substances into the alginate solution during membrane fabrication. These porogens create pores within the membrane structure upon their removal, influencing pore size distribution, porosity, and ultimately, membrane performance. The pore structure significantly impacts the effectiveness of alginate membranes in wastewater treatment. Porogens are materials integrated into the membrane during fabrication to create pores upon removal. Their size, distribution, and connectivity affect water permeation, contaminant rejection, and overall membrane efficacy [6]. Here, various types of porogen used to modify alginate membranes are discussed:

Inorganic porogens: A Foundation for Controlled Porosity. Among the inorganic porogens, calcium carbonate (CaCO₃) stands out. This biocompatible material offers a degree of control over pore size and distribution by varying the size and concentration of CaCO₃ particles incorporated within the alginate matrix [6]. Upon removal of CaCO₃ particles, the resulting voids contribute to the overall porosity of the membrane. However, the presence of residual CaCO₃ particles can potentially impact membrane performance and may necessitate rigorous washing procedures to ensure complete removal.

Natural polymers: Harnessing Nature’s Building Blocks. Natural polymers offer a sustainable and often biocompatible alternative to inorganic porogens. Cellulose, a ubiquitous natural polymer, has been successfully utilized to create well-defined pores within alginate membranes [3]. The size and morphology of cellulose particles significantly influence the resulting pore structure. However, complete removal of cellulose particles from the alginate matrix can pose challenges.

Lignin, a complex biopolymer derived from wood, is emerging as a promising porogen for alginate membranes. Its complex structure and potential for creating hierarchical pore structures make it an attractive candidate [6]. However, research on lignin’s efficacy as a porogen for alginate membranes is still in its early stages, requiring further investigation and optimization to fully realize its potential.

Starch, another readily available natural polymer, serves as a biocompatible porogen for alginate membranes. Upon removal, starch granules leave behind interconnected pores within the alginate matrix, potentially enhancing membrane permeability [8]. However, it is crucial to consider the potential for starch degradation in specific wastewater conditions, as this could compromise the long-term stability of the membrane.

Beyond the conventional: Exploring Novel Porogens. Beyond traditional inorganic and natural polymers, researchers are exploring other innovative porogens to tailor the properties of alginate membranes. Naphthalene, a volatile organic compound (VOC), has been extensively used as a porogen for alginate membranes. Upon removal, naphthalene leaves behind an interconnected pore network, potentially enhancing water permeability. However, the volatile nature of naphthalene raises environmental concerns. Residual naphthalene can adversely impact membrane performance and pose potential health risks, necessitating careful removal procedures to minimize environmental impact.

The ice crystal templating method offers a unique approach to creating defined pores within alginate membranes [6]. By freezing and subsequently melting ice crystals within the alginate matrix, researchers can precisely control pore size and distribution. While this method offers a high degree of control, its implementation on an industrial scale may present significant challenges.

The choice of porogen significantly influences the final properties of alginate membranes, including pore size, distribution, and interconnectivity. By carefully selecting the appropriate porogen, researchers can tailor the membrane’s properties to specific applications, such as water filtration, drug delivery, and tissue engineering. Ongoing research continues to explore novel porogens and optimize existing methods to create high-performance alginate membranes with enhanced functionality.

Selecting the optimal porogen for alginate membrane development

The judicious selection of a porogen is paramount in tailoring alginate membranes for effective wastewater treatment. Several key factors must be considered to ensure optimal performance. Firstly, the desired pore size, distribution, and connectivity within the membrane should be carefully aligned with the specific characteristics of the target pollutants in the wastewater. For instance, membranes designed to remove large particulate matter will require larger and more interconnected pores compared to those intended for the removal of dissolved contaminants.

Biocompatibility is another crucial consideration, particularly for environmentally conscious applications. Utilizing natural polymers as porogens offers several advantages, including their inherent biodegradability and ease of removal, minimizing potential environmental impact. Moreover, the chosen porogen removal method must be efficient and preserve the structural integrity of the alginate membrane. Ideally, the porogen should be completely removable, leaving no residual particles within the membrane matrix. This ensures optimal membrane performance and minimizes the risk of potential adverse effects.

Economic feasibility and accessibility are also important factors to consider. The chosen porogen should be readily available and cost-effective to ensure the economic viability of membrane production and subsequent wastewater treatment processes.

Porogen modification is a potent approach to tailor alginate membrane pore structures, enhancing their efficacy in wastewater treatment. Careful selection and optimization of porogens can yield membranes with high permeability, effective pollutant rejection, and suitability for specific wastewater types such as slaughterhouse effluents. Choosing the right porogen based on pore characteristics, biocompatibility, and environmental impact is critical. Subsequent sections will explore additional membrane modification techniques, including stabilizers and anti-fouling agents, to further enhance the properties and applicability of alginate membranes in wastewater treatment.

Fortifying alginate membranes: Strategies for enhanced mechanical stability

Alginate membranes, while offering numerous advantages such as biocompatibility and ease of processing, can exhibit limitations in terms of mechanical durability, particularly when exposed to harsh or dynamic environments encountered in wastewater treatment. To address this challenge, researchers have explored various strategies to enhance the mechanical strength and stability of these promising biomaterials. One of the most crucial approaches involves the incorporation of stabilizers within the alginate matrix. These additives act as reinforcing agents, providing the membrane with the necessary resilience to withstand the rigors of wastewater treatment processes.

Crosslinking: A Foundation for Enhanced Stability. Crosslinking plays a pivotal role in the fabrication of alginate membranes using the dissolution-gelation method. Traditional crosslinking agents, such as divalent cations like calcium (Ca²⁺), form ionic bonds with the alginate chains, creating a three-dimensional network that imparts initial structural integrity. However, the mechanical strength imparted by calcium crosslinking may not always be sufficient for demanding applications.

Researchers have explored alternative crosslinking agents to enhance the mechanical stability of alginate membranes. For instance, zirconium (Zr4+) has emerged as a promising candidate due to its ability to form stronger and more stable crosslinks with alginate compared to calcium. Liu, et al. [19] demonstrated that Zr4+ crosslinked membranes exhibited significantly improved mechanical strength and stability compared to their calcium-crosslinked counterparts, highlighting the potential of this approach in enhancing membrane durability.

Polymer reinforcement: Synergistic Blends for Enhanced Performance. Blending alginate with other polymers offers a versatile strategy for improving its mechanical properties. The incorporation of synthetic or natural polymers can create synergistic effects, resulting in composite membranes with enhanced strength, flexibility, and resistance to degradation.

Augustus, et al. [6] investigated the potential of blending alginate with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), a synthetic polymer known for its excellent mechanical properties. Their research demonstrated that the resulting composite membranes exhibited superior mechanical strength and resistance to degradation in saline environments, making them suitable for applications in challenging wastewater treatment scenarios. The synergistic interaction between alginate and PVA contributes to a more robust and resilient membrane structure.

Clay minerals: Reinforcing Alginate with Natural Inorganics. Clay minerals, such as montmorillonite, offer a unique approach to enhancing the mechanical properties of alginate membranes. These naturally occurring layered silicates can be incorporated into the alginate matrix, acting as reinforcing fillers. Darwish, et al. [22] demonstrated that the incorporation of montmorillonite into alginate membranes significantly enhanced their mechanical strength and barrier properties. The presence of clay platelets within the alginate matrix can effectively reinforce the membrane structure, providing improved resistance to deformation and rupture.

Biopolymer reinforcement: Harnessing Nature’s Building Blocks. Biocompatible biopolymers derived from natural sources offer a sustainable and environmentally friendly approach to enhancing the mechanical stability of alginate membranes. Xyloglucan, a plant cell wall polysaccharide, has emerged as a promising stabilizer for alginate membranes due to its excellent film-forming properties and compatibility with biological systems.

Aderibigbe, et al. [23] investigated the use of xyloglucan extracted from Afzelia Africana, an African hardwood tree, to reinforce alginate membranes. Their research demonstrated that the incorporation of xyloglucan not only improved the mechanical stability of the membranes but also enhanced their biodegradability, suggesting potential applications in environmentally sustainable wastewater treatment systems. The use of biopolymers like xyloglucan aligns with the growing interest in developing sustainable and eco-friendly materials for environmental applications.

The development of mechanically robust alginate membranes is crucial for their successful application in challenging wastewater treatment environments. By incorporating stabilizers such as crosslinking agents, synthetic and natural polymers, clay minerals, and biopolymers, researchers can significantly enhance the mechanical properties of these biomaterials.

Crosslinking agents, particularly those beyond traditional calcium ions, offer the potential to create stronger and more stable alginate networks. Polymer blending provides a versatile approach to tailoring the mechanical properties of alginate membranes by combining the unique characteristics of different polymers. The incorporation of clay minerals and biopolymers offers sustainable and environmentally friendly strategies for reinforcing alginate membranes, aligning with the growing emphasis on developing eco-friendly and sustainable solutions for environmental challenges.

Continued research and development in this area are crucial to further optimize the selection and incorporation of stabilizers, leading to the creation of high-performance alginate membranes with exceptional mechanical stability and durability for a wide range of wastewater treatment applications.

Combating membrane fouling: Strategies for enhanced alginate membrane

Performance: Membrane fouling, the accumulation of organic and inorganic matter on the membrane surface, presents a significant obstacle in wastewater treatment operations. This phenomenon leads to a decline in membrane permeability, increased energy consumption, and ultimately, reduced treatment efficiency. To mitigate these challenges, researchers have focused on incorporating anti-fouling agents within the alginate membrane structure. These additives act as a shield against fouling, enhancing membrane longevity and ensuring sustained performance in real-world applications.

A spectrum of anti-fouling strategies: A variety of approaches are employed to impart anti-fouling properties to alginate membranes. One prominent strategy involves the incorporation of hydrophilic modifiers. These molecules, often incorporating hydrophilic groups such as polyethylene glycol (PEG), create a hydrophilic surface layer on the membrane. This hydrophilic layer acts as a water barrier, repelling hydrophobic foulants and minimizing their adhesion to the membrane surface. By reducing the interaction between the membrane and foulants, hydrophilic modifiers effectively minimize fouling and maintain high flux rates.

Clay minerals, such as kaolin, offer a multifaceted approach to mitigating fouling. In addition to their role in enhancing mechanical stability, as discussed earlier, clay minerals can also function as effective anti-fouling agents [22]. The incorporation of clay particles within the alginate matrix can alter the surface properties of the membrane, creating a less adhesive surface for foulants. Furthermore, the presence of clay particles can act as a physical barrier, hindering the penetration of foulants into the deeper layers of the membrane.

Expanding the horizon of anti-fouling strategies: Beyond the aforementioned approaches, ongoing research continues to explore novel and advanced anti-fouling strategies to further enhance the performance and durability of alginate membranes in wastewater treatment. A significant focus is on the development of sustainable and environmentally friendly anti-fouling agents. This includes the exploration of biologically derived materials, such as biopolymers and natural extracts, to minimize the environmental impact of the membrane treatment process.

The incorporation of bio-inspired surface modifications, such as mimicking the anti-fouling properties of natural surfaces like lotus leaves and shark skin, is another promising area of research. These approaches aim to create highly effective and durable anti-fouling coatings that minimize the need for frequent membrane cleaning and maintenance, thereby improving the overall sustainability and economic viability of wastewater treatment operations.

The role of surface charge engineering: Modifying the surface charge of the alginate membrane can also significantly impact its fouling resistance. By introducing charged functional groups onto the membrane surface, it is possible to repel similarly charged foulants, thereby minimizing their adhesion. This can be achieved through various techniques, such as grafting charged polymers onto the membrane surface or incorporating charged nanoparticles within the alginate matrix.

Understanding fouling mechanisms: A Key to Effective Anti-Fouling Strategies. A deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms of membrane fouling is crucial for the development of effective anti-fouling strategies. This includes investigating the interactions between foulants and the membrane surface, analyzing the factors that influence foulant deposition, and characterizing the properties of the fouling layer. By gaining a more comprehensive understanding of these complex processes, researchers can design and develop more effective and targeted anti-fouling strategies.

Computational modeling and simulation: Predicting and Optimizing Anti-Fouling Performance. Computational modeling and simulation techniques are increasingly being used to predict and optimize the anti-fouling performance of alginate membranes. These tools can be used to simulate the interactions between foulants and the membrane surface, predict fouling rates under different operating conditions, and evaluate the effectiveness of different anti-fouling strategies. By utilizing these computational approaches, researchers can accelerate the development of more effective and efficient anti-fouling solutions [9].

Integrating anti-fouling strategies with other membrane modifications: Combining anti-fouling strategies with other membrane modifications, such as enhancing mechanical stability and incorporating self-cleaning mechanisms, can lead to significant improvements in overall membrane performance. For example, integrating hydrophilic modifiers with clay minerals can create a synergistic effect, providing enhanced anti-fouling properties and improved mechanical stability [9].

Future outlook: Towards Advanced Anti-Fouling Solutions. The development of advanced anti-fouling strategies for alginate membranes is an ongoing and dynamic field of research. Continued advancements in materials science, nanotechnology, and bioengineering will undoubtedly lead to the development of novel and innovative solutions for mitigating membrane fouling.

The integration of artificial intelligence and machine learning techniques is also expected to play a crucial role in the future development of anti-fouling strategies. These tools can be used to analyze large datasets, identify key parameters that influence fouling, and optimize the design of anti-fouling coatings for specific applications.

The development of effective anti-fouling strategies is crucial for ensuring the long-term performance and sustainability of alginate membranes in wastewater treatment applications. By exploring a diverse range of approaches, including the incorporation of hydrophilic modifiers, utilizing the unique properties of clay minerals, and developing novel bio-inspired solutions, researchers are continuously striving to create more fouling-resistant membranes.

Continued advancements in materials science, nanotechnology, and computational modeling, coupled with a deeper understanding of fouling mechanisms, will undoubtedly lead to the development of highly effective and durable anti-fouling strategies. These advancements will not only improve the efficiency and reliability of wastewater treatment processes but also contribute to the development of more sustainable and environmentally friendly technologies for addressing global water challenges [9].

Selecting the optimal anti-fouling strategy: A tailored approach

The selection of an appropriate anti-fouling agent for a specific wastewater treatment application requires a nuanced and tailored approach. The efficacy of the chosen agent is directly linked to the specific composition of the wastewater and the predominant fouling mechanisms at play. A thorough understanding of the types of foulants present (organic matter, inorganic particles, colloidal substances), their characteristics (size, charge, hydrophobicity), and their tendency to adhere to the membrane surface is crucial for selecting the most effective anti-fouling strategy.

The chosen anti-fouling agent must demonstrate high efficacy against the targeted foulants in the specific wastewater stream. It should effectively repel or prevent the adhesion of these foulants, minimizing their impact on membrane performance. Furthermore, the anti-fouling agent must be compatible with the alginate matrix, ensuring that its incorporation does not compromise the inherent properties of the alginate membrane, such as its biocompatibility, biodegradability, and mechanical strength. The agent should integrate seamlessly within the alginate matrix without altering its desirable properties or introducing unintended side effects.

Future considerations: Paving the Way for Advanced Anti-Fouling Solutions. Ongoing research continues to explore novel and advanced anti-fouling strategies to further enhance the performance and durability of alginate membranes in wastewater treatment. A significant focus is on the development of sustainable and environmentally friendly anti-fouling agents. This includes the exploration of biologically derived materials, such as biopolymers and natural extracts, to minimize the environmental impact of the membrane treatment process.

The incorporation of bio-inspired surface modifications, such as mimicking the anti-fouling properties of natural surfaces like lotus leaves and shark skin, is another promising area of research. These approaches aim to create highly effective and durable anti-fouling coatings that minimize the need for frequent membrane cleaning and maintenance, thereby improving the overall sustainability and economic viability of wastewater treatment operations.

The selection and development of effective anti-fouling strategies for alginate membranes is an ongoing and crucial endeavor in the field of wastewater treatment. By carefully considering the specific characteristics of the wastewater and the desired performance objectives, researchers can select the most appropriate anti-fouling agents and optimize their incorporation within the alginate matrix.

Continued research and development efforts are essential to explore novel and sustainable anti-fouling solutions, ultimately leading to the creation of high-performance alginate membranes with enhanced fouling resistance and extended operational lifetimes. These advancements will contribute significantly to the development of more efficient, sustainable, and environmentally friendly wastewater treatment technologies [9].

Fine-tuning alginate membranes: Statistical methods for wastewater treatment

Building high-performing, efficient alginate membranes for wastewater treatment requires fine-tuning the fabrication process. Response Surface Methodology (RSM) is a powerful statistical tool that helps us achieve this. Let’s explore how RSM can optimize alginate membrane fabrication and the benefits it offers for wastewater treatment.

Central composite design in RSM: RSM uses a combination of statistical and mathematical techniques to analyze the connections between multiple factors (independent variables) we can control during fabrication and the desired outcome [24]. Central Composite Design (CCD) is a popular design within RSM, providing a structured way to run optimization experiments.

The Controlled Composition Design (CCD) method for alginate membrane fabrication involves several key factors that can be precisely controlled to enhance membrane performance. These factors include the concentration of the alginate solution, the type and amount of crosslinking agents, such as calcium chloride, and the use of porogens if applicable. Additionally, the curing time or temperature and the stirring speed during membrane casting are crucial parameters. The desired outcomes of this method focus on improving the membrane’s permeability to allow more pure water to pass through, enhancing its efficiency in removing specific pollutants, such as organic matter and heavy metals, and increasing the overall strength of the membrane.

Why CCD is great for optimizing alginate membranes: Central Composite Design (CCD) offers several advantages for optimizing the fabrication of alginate membranes. Firstly, it significantly reduces the number of experiments required compared to traditional “one-factor-at-a-time” approaches. This efficiency gain translates to reduced time and resource consumption in the research process [9].

Furthermore, CCD excels at uncovering not only the individual effects of various factors on membrane properties but also the intricate interactions between these factors. For example, the influence of alginate concentration on membrane permeability might be significantly impacted by the amount of crosslinking agent used [9]. By systematically exploring these interactions, researchers gain a deeper understanding of the complex interplay between different processing parameters and the resulting membrane characteristics.

Finally, CCD facilitates the development of predictive mathematical models using Response Surface Methodology (RSM). These models can accurately predict the outcome (e.g., permeability, mechanical strength) within the explored range of factors. This predictive capability empowers researchers to pinpoint the optimal combination of factors to achieve the desired membrane properties with greater precision and efficiency [9].

RSM in action: Optimizing Alginate Membranes. RSM has proven successful in fine-tuning alginate membrane creation for wastewater treatment, as shown by various studies:

Shahid, et al. [9] used RSM to optimize porosity and rejection for removing industrial pollutants. They found the ideal combination of alginate concentration and porogen type to achieve high rejection while maintaining good water flow. Darwish, et al. [8] applied RSM to optimize alginate/cellulose nanofiber membranes for oily wastewater. They focused on factors like alginate concentration, cellulose content, and crosslinking to balance water attraction, strength, and oil rejection. RSM, especially CCD, is a valuable tool for researchers and engineers to systematically optimize alginate membrane fabrication for wastewater treatment. By identifying the ideal combination of factors influencing membrane properties, RSM helps develop efficient and high-performing alginate membranes for various wastewater treatment applications. Combining RSM with other optimization techniques like artificial intelligence or machine learning could further advance membrane optimization. Additionally, incorporating environmental and economic factors could lead to the development of sustainable and cost-effective alginate membranes for wastewater treatment.

Myco-phycoremediation approaches for wastewater treatment

Conventional wastewater treatment, though effective, can create extra waste and use a lot of energy. Biological approaches like mycoremediation offer a sustainable and efficient alternative. This section explores how fungi can be used to treat wastewater (mycoremediation).

Application of fungi in mycoremediation processes: Conventional wastewater treatment methods, while effective, often involve significant energy consumption and can generate substantial amounts of sludge as a byproduct. This necessitates the exploration of more sustainable and eco-friendly alternatives. Mycoremediation, a bioremediation technique that utilizes the metabolic capabilities of fungi, offers a promising approach for treating a wide range of wastewater pollutants.

Fungi possess a remarkable array of enzymes capable of degrading a diverse range of organic pollutants, including recalcitrant compounds such as hydrocarbons, pharmaceuticals, and pesticides [25]. These enzymes catalyze a variety of biochemical reactions, breaking down complex pollutants into simpler, less harmful compounds.

Furthermore, fungal cell walls exhibit strong adsorptive properties. These complex structures act as biosorbents, passively binding pollutants through various mechanisms, including physical adsorption, ion exchange, and complexation [26]. This ability of fungi to bind and sequester pollutants effectively removes them from the wastewater matrix.

In addition to degradation and adsorption, certain fungal species exhibit the ability to accumulate heavy metals and other contaminants within their biomass [27]. This bioaccumulation process allows fungi to concentrate and remove pollutants from the wastewater, effectively reducing their overall concentration.

The versatility of fungi is another key advantage in the context of wastewater treatment. Many fungal species can thrive under a wide range of environmental conditions, including those characterized by high organic loads, fluctuating temperatures, and the presence of toxic compounds [28]. This adaptability makes them suitable for treating a diverse array of wastewater streams, from domestic and industrial effluents to agricultural runoff.

Microalgae applications in phycoremediation: Phycoremediation is an innovative and sustainable approach to wastewater treatment that leverages the unique capabilities of microalgae, and photosynthetic microorganisms. These microscopic organisms offer several distinct advantages for effectively treating wastewater.

Firstly, microalgae are highly efficient at removing excess nutrients, such as nitrogen and phosphorus, from wastewater. These nutrients, often present in high concentrations due to agricultural runoff and sewage discharge, can lead to eutrophication, a phenomenon characterized by excessive algal growth in water bodies. Microalgae utilize these nutrients for their own growth and reproduction, effectively mitigating nutrient pollution and preventing the degradation of water quality [29].

Secondly, some microalgae possess remarkable metabolic capabilities that enable them to degrade a wide range of complex organic pollutants. This includes recalcitrant compounds such as hydrocarbons and pharmaceuticals, which are often resistant to conventional treatment methods [16]. By incorporating these pollutant-degrading microalgae into wastewater treatment systems, it is possible to remove these harmful compounds effectively and enhance the overall water quality.

Furthermore, the biomass generated during the phycoremediation process can be utilized for various valuable applications, transforming wastewater treatment into a resource recovery process. The harvested microalgal biomass can be used as a source of biofuels, such as biodiesel and bioethanol, contributing to the development of renewable energy sources. Alternatively, it can be processed into valuable fertilizers, enriching agricultural soils and promoting sustainable agricultural practices [30].

Finally, microalgae utilize carbon dioxide (CO₂) for photosynthesis, effectively sequestering this greenhouse gas from the atmosphere. By integrating phycoremediation into wastewater treatment systems, it is possible to mitigate the environmental impact of greenhouse gas emissions while simultaneously improving water quality.

In conclusion, phycoremediation offers a promising and sustainable approach to wastewater treatment. By harnessing the unique capabilities of microalgae, it is possible to achieve efficient nutrient removal, degrade a wide range of pollutants, generate valuable biomass, and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. Continued research and development in this area will further advance the application of phycoremediation technologies and contribute to the development of more sustainable and environmentally friendly wastewater treatment solutions.

Boosting alginate membranes for wastewater treatment

Alginate membranes, derived from natural alginate biopolymer, are a promising technology for wastewater treatment due to their inherent advantages. However, various modification techniques are being explored to address limitations and enhance their performance. Here, we review recent literature on improving alginate membranes for wastewater treatment applications.

Tailoring alginate membranes for wastewater: Porogens are materials added during fabrication to create pores within the membrane structure. These pores’ size, distribution, and connections significantly impact water flow, contaminant rejection, and overall membrane performance. Researchers are exploring novel porogens like stimuli-responsive materials that can be removed under specific conditions (e.g., temperature, pH) [6]. Additionally, there’s growing interest in sustainable and recyclable porogens to minimize environmental impact [8].

Choosing the right porogen is crucial for controlling pore structure, directly influencing permeability and how well the membrane targets pollutants. Studies by Shahid, et al. [9] and Darwish, et al. [8] demonstrate the effectiveness of using porogens like calcium carbonate, natural polymers (starch, cellulose), and ice crystals to create well-defined pores, leading to enhanced water permeability and improved rejection of organic pollutants from wastewater.

The selection of an appropriate porogen significantly influences the final properties of the resulting alginate membrane. A variety of materials can be employed as porogens, each with its own set of advantages and drawbacks.

Inorganic materials, such as calcium carbonate, are widely used due to their biocompatibility and relative ease of removal. However, challenges can arise from the potential presence of residual particles, which may adversely affect membrane performance [6].

Natural polymers, including readily available and biocompatible materials like starch and cellulose, offer attractive alternatives. However, their use can be complicated by challenges associated with incomplete removal and the potential for degradation under certain conditions [3,8].

The ice crystal templating method provides a high degree of control over pore size and distribution within the alginate matrix. However, the implementation of this technique on a large scale can present significant logistical and technical challenges [6].

While naphthalene offers high efficiency as a porogen, its classification as a Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) raises significant environmental concerns. The potential for residual naphthalene to adversely impact membrane performance and pose health risks necessitates careful handling and thorough removal procedures.

The focus on sustainable approaches has led to research on biocompatible porogens like natural polymers. Clementi, et al. [3] discussed the potential of lignin, a readily available biopolymer, as a porogen for alginate membranes. However, further research is needed to optimize its effectiveness.

Alginate membranes can be weak, especially in harsh wastewater conditions. Stabilizers are additives incorporated into the membrane structure to enhance strength and prevent degradation. Research is focusing on developing novel biocompatible and sustainable stabilizers like those derived from natural resources (e.g., cellulose nanofibers) [3]. Additionally, stabilizers are being explored that offer additional functionalities, such as improved antifouling properties [31].

Keeping membranes clean

Anti-fouling strategies: A major challenge in wastewater treatment is membrane fouling. Organic and inorganic materials build up on the membrane surface, slowing water flow and reducing performance. Anti-fouling agents are additives incorporated into membranes to minimize fouling and maintain long-term efficiency. Research is actively exploring novel anti-fouling agents with improved effectiveness and long-term stability. This includes exploring self-cleaning membranes and agents that respond to external stimuli (e.g., light, pH) for controlled release and targeted action [6].

Adding hydrophilic polymers like polyethylene glycol

(PEG) creates a surface that attracts water, reducing the adhesion of organic foulants. Wang, et al. [32] showed the effectiveness of PEG modification for enhancing the antifouling properties of alginate membranes when treating oily wastewater.

Charged polymers, like zwitterionic polymers, offer a broader anti-fouling effect by repelling both organic and inorganic foulants. Zhang, et al. [33] explored using zwitterionic polymers to fabricate alginate membranes with superior antifouling properties for municipal wastewater treatment.

Incorporating nanoparticles with antimicrobial properties, such as silver nanoparticles, can offer targeted anti-fouling action. However, the potential environmental impact of nanoparticles requires careful consideration.

Extracts from natural sources, like seaweed or plant extracts, are being investigated for their potential as anti-fouling agents due to their biocompatibility and environmentally friendly nature. Augustus, et al. [6] highlight the need for further research to explore their effectiveness in different wastewater streams. Several studies have shown success in using RSM to fine-tune alginate membrane creation for wastewater treatment. Shahid, et al. [9] leveraged RSM to optimize porosity and rejection in alginate membranes for removing industrial pollutants. Their RSM model pinpointed the ideal combination of alginate concentration and porogen type to achieve high rejection while maintaining good water flow. Darwish, et al. [8] applied RSM to optimize alginate/cellulose nanofiber membranes for oily wastewater. Their focus was on optimizing factors like alginate concentration, cellulose nanofiber content, and crosslinking agent concentration to strike a balance between water attraction, strength, and oil rejection efficiency.

Advantages of employing RSM in membrane research: Response Surface Methodology (RSM) offers a powerful statistical framework for optimizing complex processes, such as the fabrication of alginate membranes for wastewater treatment. Compared to traditional one-factor-at-a-time approaches, RSM utilizes a statistically designed set of experiments, significantly reducing the number of trials required to investigate the influence of multiple factors on the desired response (e.g., membrane flux, selectivity, or fouling resistance). This efficiency gain translates to substantial savings in terms of time, resources, and experimental effort.

Furthermore, RSM goes beyond simply evaluating the individual effects of each factor. It systematically explores the interactions between different process parameters. This can reveal unexpected synergies or antagonistic effects that may not be apparent from single-factor experiments. For instance, RSM might uncover that increasing the concentration of one component while simultaneously adjusting another may lead to a significant improvement in membrane performance beyond what could be achieved by altering either factor independently. This deeper understanding of the interplay between process variables allows for more informed and effective process optimization.

RSM generates mathematical models that predict the response (e.g., membrane performance) based on the combination of input factors. These models provide valuable insights into the relationship between process variables and the desired outcome. Researchers can utilize these models to identify the optimal settings for the input factors to achieve the desired membrane properties, such as high flux, high selectivity, and excellent fouling resistance. This predictive capability empowers researchers to make informed decisions and optimize the fabrication process for specific applications.

The applications of RSM extend beyond the optimization of membrane fabrication processes. It can be effectively employed to optimize various aspects of the overall wastewater treatment process itself. For example, RSM can be used to:

Optimize the operating conditions of membrane filtration units: This includes parameters such as transmembrane pressure, flow rate, and backwash frequency, to maximize treatment efficiency and minimize energy consumption. Optimize the integration of membrane filtration with other treatment processes: This can involve investigating the optimal sequence and operating conditions for combined processes, such as membrane filtration followed by biological treatment, to achieve the highest possible treatment efficiency and effluent quality.

Optimize the use of chemicals in the treatment process: RSM can be used to determine the optimal dosage and application methods for coagulants, flocculants, and other chemicals used in the pretreatment or post-treatment stages of wastewater treatment.

By employing RSM to optimize various aspects of the wastewater treatment process, researchers can significantly enhance the overall efficiency, effectiveness, and sustainability of these critical systems.

Integrating alginate membranes with mycoremediation and phycoremediation for sustainable wastewater treatment

Traditional wastewater treatment methods often generate substantial amounts of sludge as a byproduct and require significant energy input, raising concerns about their environmental sustainability. Recognizing this, researchers are exploring innovative approaches that combine the advantages of biological treatment processes with the unique properties of alginate membranes. This synergistic approach, termed alginate membrane-supported myco-phycoremediation, holds immense promise for developing more sustainable and efficient wastewater treatment solutions.

Alginate membranes can serve as effective pre-filters in wastewater treatment systems. By physically removing large particles, suspended solids, and other particulate matter from the incoming wastewater, alginate membranes significantly enhance the efficiency of subsequent biological treatment stages, such as mycoremediation (using fungi) and phycoremediation (using algae) [32]. This pre-filtration step not only protects downstream biological treatment units from clogging but also improves the overall treatment efficiency by reducing the load of suspended solids that need to be processed by the biological agents.

Alginate membranes can act as versatile carriers or scaffolds for immobilizing fungal and microalgal cells. This immobilization strategy offers several advantages. Firstly, it provides a stable and controlled environment for the growth and proliferation of biological agents, enhancing their activity and treatment efficiency. Secondly, it facilitates the easy separation of biomass from the treated wastewater, enabling its recovery and potential reuse for other applications such as biofuel production or the extraction of valuable bioproducts [16]. This not only improves the sustainability of the treatment process but also opens up new avenues for resource recovery and valorization.

The porous structure of alginate membranes plays a crucial role in enhancing the mass transfer of pollutants between the wastewater and the immobilized biological agents. This facilitates the efficient uptake of pollutants by fungi and microalgae, promoting their degradation and removal from the wastewater stream [26]. The interconnected pore network within the alginate matrix allows for the rapid diffusion of pollutants to the surface of the immobilized cells, maximizing their contact and interaction with the biological agents.

Alginate membrane-supported myco-phycoremediation represents a promising approach for developing sustainable and efficient wastewater treatment solutions. By combining the advantages of alginate membranes with the inherent bioremediation capabilities of fungi and algae, this approach offers a synergistic solution for addressing the challenges of traditional wastewater treatment methods.

Alginate membranes offer a versatile platform for integrating with biological treatment processes, such as mycoremediation (using fungi) and phycoremediation (using algae). These hybrid systems leverage the complementary strengths of both biological treatment and membrane technology, resulting in enhanced wastewater treatment efficiency and sustainability.

Fungal-alginate biocomposite membranes represent an innovative approach to mycoremediation. By incorporating fungi directly within the alginate matrix, these membranes create a symbiotic environment where the fungi can thrive while simultaneously degrading pollutants present in the wastewater permeating through the membrane [25]. The alginate matrix provides a stable and supportive environment for fungal growth, while also controlling the release of fungal enzymes and other metabolites involved in pollutant degradation.

Alternatively, fungi can be encapsulated within alginate beads. These beads can then be integrated into various wastewater treatment reactors, such as bioreactors or packed bed columns. The alginate capsule provides a protective microenvironment for the fungi, shielding them from environmental stresses while allowing for the efficient diffusion of pollutants for degradation [34]. This approach offers enhanced control over fungal activity and facilitates the recovery and reuse of fungal biomass.

Alginate membranes also provide a valuable platform for integrating microalgae into wastewater treatment processes. Immobilizing microalgae within alginate beads or onto alginate membranes offers several advantages. Firstly, it facilitates controlled growth and prevents the loss of microalgal biomass, which is crucial for maximizing treatment efficiency. Secondly, it enhances the removal of nutrients, such as nitrogen and phosphorus, from wastewater, as the immobilized microalgae can efficiently uptake these nutrients for their growth and metabolism [29].

Membrane photobioreactors represent a promising integration of alginate membranes with microalgal cultures. In these systems, alginate membranes can be used to separate treated wastewater from the microalgal biomass. This allows for the continuous harvesting of microalgal biomass for various applications, such as biofuel production or animal feed, while simultaneously producing clean water. Furthermore, the harvested microalgal biomass can be recycled back into the treatment process, creating a closed-loop system that minimizes waste and maximizes resource utilization [35].

The integration of alginate membranes with mycoremediation and phycoremediation offers significant potential for developing sustainable and efficient wastewater treatment solutions. These hybrid systems leverage the complementary strengths of biological treatment processes and membrane technology, resulting in enhanced pollutant removal, improved resource recovery, and reduced environmental impact. Continued research and development in this area are crucial for further optimizing these integrated systems and realizing their full potential in addressing global water challenges.

Potential of modified alginate membranes for diverse wastewater treatment applications

Modified alginate membranes demonstrate significant potential across a wide spectrum of wastewater treatment applications. In municipal wastewater treatment, these membranes can effectively remove suspended solids, organic matter, and emerging contaminants such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products, enhancing the efficiency of primary, secondary, and tertiary treatment stages [6].

Furthermore, alginate membranes can be tailored for specific industrial wastewater streams. By incorporating appropriate modifications, these membranes can effectively remove heavy metals, dyes, and oils from effluents generated by industries such as textiles, pharmaceuticals, and food processing. This versatility, coupled with their inherent biocompatibility, makes them attractive candidates for a range of industrial wastewater treatment applications [32].

In desalination processes, alginate membranes with optimized pore structures can play a crucial role in pre-treatment stages. By effectively removing suspended solids and organic matter, these membranes can significantly reduce fouling of subsequent reverse osmosis membranes, thereby improving the overall efficiency and longevity of the desalination process [22].

The emergence of micropollutants, such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products, presents a significant challenge to traditional wastewater treatment methods. Modified alginate membranes, incorporating specific functionalities like adsorption or encapsulation capabilities, offer promising solutions for effectively removing these recalcitrant contaminants from wastewater streams [26].

Finally, hydrophobic modifications can enhance the efficiency of alginate membranes in treating oily wastewater streams, enabling the effective separation of oil and grease from industrial effluents [6].

Optimizing alginate membrane-supported myco-phycoremediation for sustainable wastewater treatment

The integration of mycoremediation (using fungi) and phycoremediation (using microalgae) with optimized alginate membranes presents a promising and sustainable approach to wastewater treatment. This synergistic system leverages the unique capabilities of fungi and microalgae to degrade pollutants and remove nutrients, while alginate membranes provide a controlled and supportive environment for these biological processes. However, further advancements are crucial to unlock the full potential of this innovative technology.

One key area for improvement lies in the design and development of novel alginate membranes. Tailoring membrane properties such as porosity, surface chemistry, and mechanical strength to suit the specific requirements of the chosen fungal and microalgal strains is crucial. For example, optimizing pore size can facilitate the diffusion of nutrients and oxygen while preventing the escape of immobilized biomass. Modifying surface properties can enhance the attachment and growth of microorganisms within the membrane matrix [29].

In-situ biomass regeneration is another critical aspect that requires further attention. Developing strategies to promote the continuous growth and regeneration of fungal and microalgal biomass within the membrane system can significantly enhance treatment efficiency and reduce the need for frequent biomass replenishment. This can be achieved through optimizing nutrient delivery, light availability, and other environmental factors within the membrane system.

Implementing automated control systems can significantly improve the operational efficiency and performance of integrated myco-phycoremediation systems. These systems can continuously monitor and adjust key environmental parameters, such as pH, nutrient levels, and dissolved oxygen, to ensure optimal conditions for microbial growth and pollutant removal [25]. Automated control can also minimize manual intervention, reduce operational costs, and improve the overall stability and reliability of the treatment process.

Optimizing wastewater pre-treatment steps before introducing the effluent to the integrated myco-phycoremediation system is crucial for maximizing treatment efficiency. Pre-treatment steps, such as screening, sedimentation, and chemical coagulation, can remove large particulate matter, reduce the organic load, and improve the overall quality of the wastewater entering the biological treatment stage [32]. This can minimize the impact of inhibitory substances on microbial activity and enhance the overall performance of the integrated system.

Co-immobilizing both fungi and microalgae within the same alginate membrane can create synergistic treatment systems. Fungi can effectively degrade complex organic pollutants, generating simpler organic compounds that can be readily utilized by microalgae. In turn, microalgae can consume these breakdown products, remove nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus from the wastewater, and produce valuable biomass as a byproduct [35]. This symbiotic relationship can significantly enhance the overall treatment efficiency and resource recovery potential of the integrated system.

Navigating the uncharted territory: knowledge gaps in alginate membrane technology

While significant progress has been made in developing and modifying alginate membranes for wastewater treatment applications, several critical knowledge gaps remain to be addressed. These knowledge gaps hinder the full realization of the potential of alginate membranes and their integration with biological treatment processes.

Uncertainties in Long-Term Performance: One of the primary knowledge gaps lies in understanding the long-term stability and effectiveness of various modification techniques. While promising results have been observed in short-term studies, the long-term performance of alginate membranes modified with specific stabilizers, such as xyloglucan, remains largely unexplored [14]. Similarly, the long-term anti-fouling performance of kaolin-modified membranes in real-world wastewater treatment settings requires further investigation [8]. Long-term studies are crucial to assess the durability of these modifications under continuous operation and to evaluate their ability to withstand the challenges posed by fluctuating wastewater conditions.

Unveiling the Mechanisms of Action: A deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms of action of various stabilizers is essential for optimizing their use in alginate membrane fabrication. For instance, while xyloglucan has shown promise in enhancing the mechanical strength of alginate membranes, the precise mechanisms through which it interacts with the alginate matrix and imparts these beneficial properties remain unclear [14]. Elucidating these mechanisms will enable researchers to tailor the properties of xyloglucan and other stabilizers to achieve optimal performance and maximize their impact on membrane stability.

Exploring the synergistic potential of combined strategies: Current research efforts primarily focus on the individual effects of different modification techniques. However, the synergistic effects of combining multiple modification strategies remain largely unexplored. For example, the potential benefits of combining xyloglucan, a stabilizer, with anti-fouling agents like kaolin or hydrophilic polymers have not been extensively investigated [6]. Exploring these synergistic interactions could lead to the development of advanced alginate membranes with enhanced properties, surpassing the limitations of individual modification approaches. Furthermore, investigating the interplay between porogens and stabilizers within the alginate matrix could provide valuable insights into optimizing the overall membrane structure and performance.

Addressing sustainability: A Life Cycle Perspective. While the focus has been on enhancing the technical performance of alginate membranes, a comprehensive assessment of their environmental and economic sustainability is crucial. Life cycle assessment (LCA) methodologies can be employed to evaluate the environmental impacts associated with the entire lifecycle of systems integrating mycoremediation or phycoremediation with alginate membranes [32]. LCA studies can consider factors such as energy consumption, raw material usage, waste generation, and greenhouse gas emissions associated with membrane production, operation, and disposal. These assessments will provide valuable insights into the overall environmental and economic sustainability of these integrated systems, guiding the development of more eco-friendly and cost-effective wastewater treatment solutions.

Addressing these knowledge gaps is crucial for advancing the field of alginate membrane technology and its integration with biological treatment processes. By conducting long-term studies, elucidating the mechanisms of action of stabilizers, exploring the synergistic effects of combined modification strategies, and performing comprehensive life cycle assessments, researchers can refine the design and fabrication of alginate membranes, leading to the development of more sustainable, effective, and reliable solutions for wastewater treatment.

Future perspective and recommendations

The future of wastewater treatment holds immense promise for alginate membranes, particularly when their inherent limitations are addressed through innovative modifications and functional enhancements. This section delves into the potential applications of these modified membranes, explores strategies for their integration with biological treatment methods, and examines crucial factors to consider for their successful large-scale implementation (Figure 3).

Diverse applications of modified alginate membranes in wastewater treatment

Modified alginate membranes exhibit significant potential across a wide spectrum of wastewater treatment applications. In municipal wastewater treatment plants, these membranes can be strategically employed at various stages, including primary, secondary, and tertiary treatment. They demonstrate remarkable efficacy in removing suspended solids, organic matter, and emerging contaminants such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products, contributing to more efficient and sustainable treatment processes.

Furthermore, the versatility of alginate membranes can be harnessed to address the specific challenges posed by industrial wastewater. By tailoring the membrane properties through modifications, they can effectively remove targeted pollutants such as heavy metals, dyes, and oils from effluents generated by industries like textiles, pharmaceuticals, and food processing.

In desalination processes, modified alginate membranes can play a crucial role in pre-treatment stages. By efficiently removing suspended solids and organic matter, they can significantly reduce fouling in subsequent reverse osmosis membranes, thereby enhancing the overall efficiency and longevity of the desalination system.

The emergence of micropollutants, such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products, as significant contaminants in wastewater, necessitates innovative treatment solutions. Modified alginate membranes, equipped with enhanced adsorption or encapsulation capabilities, can effectively capture and remove these recalcitrant compounds, mitigating their potential environmental impact.

Finally, in the treatment of oily wastewater, commonly generated in industrial settings, alginate membranes with hydrophobic modifications can be highly effective in separating oil and grease from the aqueous phase. This capability is crucial for preventing environmental pollution and ensuring the safe disposal or reuse of oily wastewater.

Integration with biological treatment processes: The integration of modified alginate membranes with biological treatment processes presents a synergistic approach to achieving superior wastewater treatment outcomes. By combining the physical filtration capabilities of membranes with the biological degradation potential of microorganisms, this hybrid system can effectively remove a wide range of contaminants, including both particulate matter and dissolved organic compounds.

One promising approach involves the development of membrane bioreactors (MBRs), where alginate membranes are employed to separate activated sludge from the treated effluent. This allows for the retention of a high biomass concentration within the reactor, enhancing the efficiency of biological degradation processes. Furthermore, the use of alginate membranes can minimize the release of suspended solids and other pollutants into the receiving water bodies.

Factors to consider for large-scale implementation: The successful large-scale implementation of modified alginate membranes in wastewater treatment requires careful consideration of several key factors. Firstly, the economic viability of membrane production and operation is crucial. This includes the cost of raw materials, energy consumption, and the frequency of membrane cleaning and replacement.

Secondly, the long-term stability and durability of the modified membranes under real-world operating conditions are critical. This necessitates thorough testing and evaluation of membrane performance in pilot-scale studies to assess their resilience against fouling, chemical degradation, and mechanical stress.

Thirdly, the environmental impact of membrane production, operation, and disposal must be carefully evaluated. The use of sustainable materials and energy-efficient processes is essential to minimize the environmental footprint of alginate membrane technology.

Finally, the development of robust and efficient membrane cleaning strategies is crucial for maintaining optimal performance and extending the lifespan of the membranes. This may involve the development of novel cleaning agents or the integration of in-situ cleaning technologies.

In conclusion, modified alginate membranes offer a promising avenue for advancing wastewater treatment technologies. Their versatility, biocompatibility, and potential for customization make them suitable for a wide range of applications, from municipal and industrial wastewater treatment to desalination and the removal of emerging contaminants. By integrating these membranes with biological treatment processes, optimizing their performance through innovative modifications, and addressing the critical factors associated with large-scale implementation, we can harness the full potential of alginate membranes to create more sustainable and efficient wastewater treatment solutions.

Synergistic wastewater treatment: Integrating mycoremediation and phycoremediation with advanced alginate membranes

The integration of mycoremediation (using fungi) and phycoremediation (using microalgae) with optimized alginate membranes presents a compelling approach for achieving sustainable and efficient wastewater treatment. This synergistic approach leverages the unique metabolic capabilities of fungi and microalgae to degrade a wide range of pollutants, while alginate membranes provide a controlled and supportive environment for these microorganisms.

Engineering alginate membranes for enhanced bioremediation: To maximize the effectiveness of these integrated systems, significant advancements in alginate membrane design are crucial. Creating alginate membranes with precisely tailored porosity and surface properties is essential for optimal microbial growth and activity. By carefully controlling pore size and distribution, it is possible to optimize the diffusion of nutrients, oxygen, and pollutants within the membrane matrix, enhancing the accessibility of pollutants to the immobilized microorganisms. Furthermore, modifying the surface properties of the alginate membrane, such as hydrophobicity and charge, can be employed to selectively encourage the attachment and growth of specific fungal or microalgal strains, thereby enhancing the overall treatment efficiency.

In-situ biomass regeneration: Promoting Sustainable Microbial Growth. Implementing strategies that support the in-situ growth and regeneration of fungal and microalgal biomass within the membrane system is critical for long-term sustainability. This can be achieved through the incorporation of nutrient sources directly within the membrane matrix or by developing innovative strategies for continuous nutrient delivery. By minimizing the reliance on external nutrient supplements, these integrated systems can be made more self-sufficient and reduce operational costs.

Optimizing pre-treatment for enhanced bioremediation: Effective pre-treatment of wastewater before it enters the integrated mycoremediation-phycoremediation system is crucial for maximizing treatment efficiency. Pre-treatment steps, such as screening, sedimentation, and chemical coagulation, can remove large particulate matter, reduce the organic load, and neutralize harmful chemicals. By minimizing the presence of inhibitory substances and reducing the overall treatment load, pre-treatment can significantly enhance the performance of the biological treatment stages within the integrated system.

Co-immobilization of fungi and microalgae: Creating Synergistic Communities. Developing alginate membranes to co-immobilize both fungi and microalgae within the same matrix can create synergistic treatment systems. Fungi, with their diverse metabolic capabilities, can effectively degrade complex organic pollutants, while microalgae can efficiently remove nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus. The co-existence of these microorganisms can create a symbiotic relationship, where the degradation products of fungal metabolism can serve as nutrients for microalgal growth, and vice versa. This synergistic interaction can lead to enhanced pollutant removal efficiency and improved overall treatment performance.

Smart membranes for controlled nutrient delivery: Designing alginate membranes with the capability for controlled nutrient release can significantly improve the efficiency and sustainability of these integrated systems. By incorporating nutrient-releasing agents within the membrane matrix, it is possible to provide a continuous and controlled supply of essential nutrients to the immobilized biomass. This approach can optimize microbial growth and activity, maximizing treatment performance while minimizing nutrient wastage.

Advanced membrane bioreactors for enhanced mass transfer: Optimizing membrane bioreactors with advanced alginate membranes can significantly enhance mass transfer within the system. By incorporating features such as improved mixing, increased surface area, and optimized flow patterns, it is possible to facilitate the rapid and efficient transport of pollutants, nutrients, and oxygen within the membrane matrix. This enhanced mass transfer can lead to more rapid and complete pollutant removal, resulting in improved treatment efficiency and reduced treatment times.

The integration of mycoremediation and phycoremediation with optimized alginate membranes presents a promising avenue for developing sustainable and efficient wastewater treatment technologies. By advancing membrane design, optimizing pre-treatment processes, and fostering synergistic microbial interactions, it is possible to create highly effective and environmentally friendly treatment systems. Continued research and development in this area are crucial to further refine these integrated systems and realize their full potential in addressing the growing challenges of water pollution.

Scaling up and implementing modified alginate membranes in wastewater treatment

The successful translation of laboratory-scale demonstrations to large-scale applications of modified alginate membranes in real-world wastewater treatment settings requires careful consideration of various critical factors.

Economic feasibility: Achieving Cost-Effectiveness in Large-Scale Production. Developing cost-effective manufacturing processes for large-scale production of modified alginate membranes is paramount for their widespread adoption. This necessitates optimizing production techniques to minimize material costs, reduce energy consumption, and maximize production efficiency. Furthermore, exploring alternative and potentially lower-cost sources of alginate and other raw materials can significantly contribute to reducing production costs.

Engineering for practical application: Designing Efficient Membrane Modules. The design and configuration of membrane modules play a crucial role in determining the overall performance and efficiency of a large-scale alginate membrane system. Optimizing flow patterns within the membrane modules is essential to minimize pressure drops, reduce energy consumption, and ensure uniform distribution of wastewater across the membrane surface. This requires careful consideration of factors such as module geometry, membrane orientation, and flow velocities.

Long-term operational considerations: Addressing Practical Challenges. Ensuring the long-term operational stability and efficiency of alginate membrane systems in real-world wastewater treatment environments requires addressing several practical challenges. Membrane fouling, the accumulation of organic and inorganic matter on the membrane surface, remains a significant concern. Developing effective cleaning protocols, including chemical cleaning agents and physical cleaning methods, is crucial for maintaining membrane performance and extending its lifespan.

Furthermore, ensuring the durability of the modified alginate membranes over time is critical. This requires careful consideration of factors such as the stability of the modifications, the impact of harsh chemical environments, and the potential for degradation under operating conditions.

Integration with existing infrastructure: Seamless Transition to Real-World Applications. Integrating alginate membrane technologies into existing wastewater treatment facilities requires careful planning and consideration. This may involve modifying existing infrastructure, such as upgrading pumping systems or installing new piping networks, to accommodate the specific requirements of the membrane system.

Furthermore, integrating alginate membrane technology with existing biological treatment processes, such as activated sludge or bioreactors, can offer significant benefits. For example, the use of alginate membranes can enhance the removal of specific pollutants, such as heavy metals or emerging contaminants, that may not be effectively removed by conventional biological treatment alone.

Life cycle assessment: Evaluating Environmental and Economic Impacts. Conducting comprehensive life cycle assessments (LCAs) is crucial for understanding the overall environmental and economic impacts of alginate membrane technologies. LCAs can help evaluate the environmental footprint of the entire life cycle of the membrane, from raw material extraction and processing to manufacturing, transportation, operation, and eventual disposal. This information can be used to identify potential environmental hotspots and optimize the design and operation of membrane systems to minimize their environmental impact.

Bridging gaps and fostering collaboration: Addressing the challenges associated with scaling up and implementing modified alginate membranes requires a multidisciplinary approach. Fostering strong collaboration among researchers, engineers, and policymakers is crucial for bridging existing knowledge gaps, developing cost-effective scale-up strategies, and facilitating the successful integration of these technologies into real-world wastewater treatment applications.

Synergistic integration with biological treatment processes: Exploring New Frontiers. The integration of alginate membrane technology with biological treatment processes, such as mycoremediation (using fungi) and phycoremediation (using algae), offers significant promise for achieving sustainable and efficient wastewater management solutions. For example, alginate membranes can be used to pre-treat wastewater, removing suspended solids and other contaminants before they enter biological treatment reactors. This can improve the performance of biological processes, reduce their energy consumption, and enhance overall treatment efficiency.

Furthermore, alginate membranes can be integrated with bioreactors containing immobilized microorganisms or plant-based systems. This can create hybrid treatment systems that leverage the complementary strengths of both biological and membrane-based technologies, resulting in more efficient and sustainable wastewater treatment solutions.

The successful translation of modified alginate membranes from the laboratory to real-world applications requires a multi-faceted approach that addresses the challenges of cost-effective production, efficient module design, long-term operational stability, and seamless integration with existing wastewater treatment infrastructure. By focusing on these critical factors and fostering strong collaboration among researchers, engineers, and policymakers, we can unlock the full potential of alginate membrane technology and contribute to the development of more sustainable and efficient wastewater treatment solutions for a growing global population.

In conclusion, alginate-based membranes have emerged as a promising and versatile technology for sustainable wastewater treatment. This study has comprehensively explored the fabrication techniques, modification strategies, and applications of these membranes. Alginate’s inherent biocompatibility, biodegradability, and gel-forming properties of alginate provide a strong foundation for developing effective and environmentally friendly water purification solutions.

The paper highlights the significance of optimizing fabrication parameters, such as alginate concentration, crosslinking agents, and the incorporation of porogens, to achieve desired membrane properties. Techniques like Response Surface Methodology (RSM) have proven invaluable in identifying optimal conditions for specific wastewater treatment applications. Moreover, the integration of alginate membranes with biological treatment processes, such as phycoremediation and mycoremediation, offers a synergistic approach to enhance pollutant removal and nutrient recovery.

While alginate membranes demonstrate significant potential, challenges such as mechanical strength, long-term stability, and fouling resistance remain. Future research should focus on addressing these limitations through innovative approaches, including the development of novel crosslinking strategies, the incorporation of advanced nanomaterials, and the optimization of membrane surface properties.

By continuing to explore the potential of alginate-based membranes and addressing the identified challenges, researchers can contribute to the development of sustainable and effective solutions for wastewater treatment, ultimately safeguarding our water resources and promoting a healthier environment.

Although AI-generated tools were used to generate this Article, the concepts and central ideas it contains were entirely original and devised by a human writer. The AI merely assisted in the writing process, but the creative vision and intellectual property belong to the human author.

1. Shannon MA, Bohn PW, Elimelech M, Georgiadis JG, Benito BJ, Mayes AM. Science and technology for water purification in the coming decades. Nature. 2008;452:301–310. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature06599
2. Li L, Zhao J, Sun Y, Yu F, Ma J. Ionically cross-linked sodium alginate/κ-carrageenan double-network gel beads with low-swelling, enhanced mechanical properties, and excellent adsorption performance. Chem Eng J. 2019;372:1091-1103. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2019.05.007
3. Clementi A, Egger D, Charwat V, Kasper C. Cell culture conditions: Cultivation of stem cells under dynamic conditions. In: Cell Engineering and Regeneration. Springer; 2020;415–447. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-08831-0_58
4. Wong S, Ngadi N, Inuwa IM, Hassan O. Recent advances in applications of activated carbon from biowaste for wastewater treatment: A short review. J Clean Prod. 2018;175:361-375. Available from: https://www.scirp.org/reference/referencespapers?referenceid=2407312
5. Zheng Z, Ali A, Su J, Fan Y, Zhang S. Layered double hydroxide modified biochar combined with sodium alginate: a powerful biomaterial for enhancing bioreactor performance to remove nitrate. Bioresour Technol. 2021;323:124630. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2020.124630
6. Augustus OO, Kusworo A, Montoya AI. Review of alginate-based membranes for wastewater treatment. Sustain Environ Res. 2021;29:25.
7. Li H, Jin R, Hu H, Kianpoor KY, Zhao Y, Gao Y, et al. Adsorption of As (III), Pb (II), and Zn (II) from wastewater by sodium alginate modified materials. J Anal Methods Chem. 2021;2021:7527848. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/7527848
8. Darwish NB, Abdullah A, Abdulrahman A, Hamad A, Nidal H. Experimental investigation of forward osmosis process for boron removal from water. J Water Process Eng. 2020;38:101570. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jwpe.2020.101570
9. Shahid MU, Najam T, Islam M, Hassan AM, Assiri MA, Rauf A, et al. Engineering of metal organic framework (MOF) membrane for wastewater treatment: Synthesis, applications and future challenges. J Water Process Eng. 2024;57:104676. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jwpe.2023.104676
10. Peng Y, Li J, Lu J, Xiao L, Yang L. Characteristics of microbial community involved in early biofilms formation under the influence of wastewater treatment plant effluent. J Environ Sci. 2018;66:113-124. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jes.2017.05.015
11. Xu Y, Wang B, Wang G, Zhang Y. Degradation of refractory organics in the pharmaceutical wastewater by bioelectrochemical system. Chem Ind Eng Prog. 2022;41(9):5055. Available from: https://doi.org/10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2021-2421
12. Wu Y, Li H, An Y, Sun Q, Liu B, Zheng H, et al. Construction of magnetic alginate-based biosorbent and its adsorption performances for anionic organic contaminants. Sep Purif Technol. 2022;297:121566. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.seppur.2022.121566
13. Wang HW, Zhu YX, Xu M, Cai XY, Tian F. Co-application of spent mushroom substrate and PGPR alleviates tomato continuous cropping obstacle by regulating soil microbial properties. Rhizosphere. 2022;23:100563. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rhisph.2022.100563
14. Chen Y, Yan X, Zhao J, Feng H, Li P, Tong Z, et al. Preparation of the chitosan/poly (glutamic acid)/alginate polyelectrolyte complexing hydrogel and study on its drug releasing property. Carbohydr Polym. 2018;191:8-16. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbpol.2018.02.065
15. Ferreira JS, Machado ÊL, Lobo EA. Nutrient removal efficiency using microalgae in different photoperiod cycles, combined with constructed wetland in a wastewater treatment plant. Rev Ambiente Água. 2021;16:e2692. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.4136/ambi-agua.2692
16. Chen H, Zuo QT, Zhang YY. Impact factor analysis of aquatic species diversity in the Huai River Basin, China. Water Supply. 2019;19(7):2061-2071. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.2166/ws.2019.085
17. Yasar OC, Fletcher L, Camargo-Valero MA. Effect of macronutrients (carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus) on the growth of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and nutrient recovery under different trophic conditions. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 2023;30(51):111369-111381. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-023-30231-2
18. Xin X, Xie J, Li W, Lv S, He J. New insights into microbial fuel cells for saline wastewater treatment: Bioelectrogenesis evaluation, microbial interactions and salinity resource reuse. Process Saf Environ Prot. 2022;168:314-323. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.psep.2022.09.077
19. Liu XX, Hu X, Cao Y, Pang WJ, Huang JY, Guo P, et al. Biodegradation of phenanthrene and heavy metal removal by acid-tolerant Burkholderia fungorum FM-2. Front Microbiol. 2019;10:408. Available from: https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2019.00408
20. Wu J, Ma L, Chen Y, Cheng Y, Liu Y, Zha X. Catalytic ozonation of organic pollutants from bio-treated dyeing and finishing wastewater using recycled waste iron shavings as a catalyst: Removal and pathways. Water Res. 2016;92:140-148. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2016.01.053
21. Wang J, Chen H. Catalytic ozonation for water and wastewater treatment: Recent advances and perspective. Sci Total Environ. 2020;704:135249. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.135249
22. Darwish NB, Alkhudhiri A, AlRomaih H, Alalawi A, Leaper MC, Hilal N. Effect of lithium chloride additive on forward osmosis membranes performance. J Water Process Eng. 2020;33:101049. Available from: https://nchr.elsevierpure.com/en/publications/effect-of-lithium-chloride-additive-on-forward-osmosis-membranes-
23. Aderibigbe FA, Adewoye LT, Mustapha SI, Mohammed IA, Saka HB, Amosa MK, et al. The phenol removal in refinery wastewater using mixed oxides prepared by green synthesis. J Eng Res. 2021;11(2A):26-35. Available from: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5298-0325
24. Myers RH, Montgomery DC. Response Surface Methodology (RSM): Process and Product Optimization Using Designed Experiments. Wiley-Interscience Publication; 2002. p. 489-492.
25. Singh S, Kumar V, Datta S, Dhanjal DS, Sharma K, Samuel J, et al. Current advancement and future prospect of biosorbents for bioremediation. Sci Total Environ. 2020;709:135895. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.135895
26. Vijayaraghavan K, Yun YS. Bacterial biosorbents and biosorption. Biotechnol Adv. 2008;26(3):266-91. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biotechadv.2008.02.002
27. Souza CG, Colares GS, da Silva Araújo P, Machado ÊL, Lobo EA. Acute ecotoxicity and genotoxicity assessment of two wastewater treatment units. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 2020;27:10520–10527. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-019-07308-y
28. Gaur VK, Sharma P, Sirohi R, Awasthi MK, Dussap CG, Pandey A. Assessing the impact of industrial waste on environment and mitigation strategies: A comprehensive review. J Hazard Mater. 2020;398:123019. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.123019
29. Abdel-Raouf MS, Abdul-Raheim ARM. Removal of heavy metals from industrial wastewater by biomass-based materials: A review. J Pollut Eff Cont. 2017;5:180. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.4172/2375-4397.1000180
30. Muñoz R, Köllner C, Guieysse B. Biofilm photobioreactors for the treatment of industrial wastewaters. J Hazard Mater. 2009;161(1):29-34. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2008.03.018
31. Sun A, Zhan Y, Feng Q, Yang W, Dong H, Liu Y, et al. Assembly of MXene/ZnO heterojunction onto electrospun poly(arylene ether nitrile) fibrous membrane for favorable oil/water separation with high permeability and synergetic antifouling performance. J Membr Sci. 2022;663:120933. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.memsci.2022.120933
32. Sudhakar MS, Aggarwal A, Sah MK. Engineering biomaterials for the bioremediation: advances in nanotechnological approaches for heavy metals removal from natural resources. In: Emerging technologies in environmental bioremediation. Elsevier; 2020. p. 323-339. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-819860-5.00014-6
33. Zhang X, Ma J, Zheng J, Dai R, Wang X, Wang Z. Recent advances in nature-inspired antifouling membranes for water purification. Chem Eng J. 2022;432:134425. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2021.134425
34. Yu F, Cui T, Yang C, Dai X, Ma J. κ-Carrageenan/sodium alginate double-network hydrogel with enhanced mechanical properties, anti-swelling, and adsorption capacity. Chemosphere. 2019;237:124417. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.124417
35. Gouda S, Taha A. Biosorption of heavy metals as a new alternative method for wastewater treatment: A review. Egypt J Aquat Biol Fisheries. 2023;27(2):135-153. Available from: https://dx.doi.org/10.21608/ejabf.2023.291671